Comments about CoverGirl Brow & Eye Makers Brow Shaper and Eyeliner, Midnight Brown 505, 1 set:

Love the color. Works great with eyeshadow primer to make it last a lot longer in humid weather.
Have to sharpen often and point breaks easily. This site offers these pencils at a good price.

Comments about CoverGirl Brow & Eye Makers Brow Shaper and Eyeliner, Midnight Brown 505, 1 set:

I have less eyebrows so I use this to fill it in. Use it every day great filler.

Can come off easy so have to be careful.

Comments about CoverGirl Brow & Eye Makers Brow Shaper and Eyeliner, Midnight Brown 505, 1 set:

I LOVE this little pencil!! I get so many compliments on my eyebrows, even when I need to trim them. Using this pencil gives me a polished and defined look. I use this pencil every day. It literally only takes seconds to have beautiful eyebrows! I just color in my brows and go!

I would never use this as an eyeliner.

Comments about CoverGirl Brow & Eye Makers Brow Shaper and Eyeliner, Midnight Brown 505, 1 set:

This product does not apply easily at all. I had reapply several times to get it to show at all.

Comments about CoverGirl Brow & Eye Makers Brow Shaper and Eyeliner, Midnight Brown 505, 1 set:

Colour is natural and it is perfect for everyday use~

Comments about CoverGirl Brow & Eye Makers Brow Shaper and Eyeliner, Midnight Brown 505, 1 set:

I love these pencils. I use them as eyeliner and have never had any problems. They require a bit of technique, but once applied they stay on forever.

Comments about CoverGirl Brow & Eye Makers Brow Shaper and Eyeliner, Midnight Brown 505, 1 set:

These pencils are terrible. As one of the other reviewers stated, they are so waxy that it's nearly impossible to apply them as eyeliner. It tugs and pulls, and is definitely not a pencil that anyone could ever say goes on smoothly. I haven't tried using it as an eyebrow pencil, but if you're planning to use it as an eyeliner, don't waste your money. The color is also much lighter than it appears here. I usually use a dark brown eyeliner, but this was considerably lighter than any other dark brown pencil I've ever used. They need to name it something other than "midnight brown". I would never order this again and will probably trash the ones I already have because they are pretty useless.

Comments about CoverGirl Brow & Eye Makers Brow Shaper and Eyeliner, Midnight Brown 505, 1 set:

I agree with one of the reviews: it is impossible to sharpen the pencil because the wood breaks into small pieces. The same hapenes to the core. It just falls apart. It is impossible to draw a line with this pencil. Awful. Would give it not a single star.

Comments about CoverGirl Brow & Eye Makers Brow Shaper and Eyeliner, Midnight Brown 505, 1 set:

The wood pencil and wax core are of poor quality and give mediocre results about half the time. In the two-pack, one may work acceptably while the other goes entirely to waste. This disproves the theory that the sharpener is at fault. In a bad pencil, the wood may be uneven with hard spots that prevent proper sharpening, or the wax core may already have multiple breaks so that pieces fall off. Here are two hints: especially in summer, put the pencil in the freezer before use to harden the wax, and clean the sharpener with a Q-tip after every use. Why do I keep buying this terrible product? The color matches my brows and I like the sharpener.

Comments about CoverGirl Brow & Eye Makers Brow Shaper and Eyeliner, Midnight Brown 505, 1 set:

Ok, so my eyebrows are light "soft black" and i bought this thinking it would be a good color and blend in with my brows. but no, its too light. so only buy this midnight brown color if you would describe your eyebrows as being BROWN, not even a light black. the reason i didn't want to buy the black color is because i thought it would make my brows too dark. but i think that color would have been better.
and as an eyebrow pencil itself, this is a good product because when you apply it the lines are not thick, they are very thin, so you can apply it in little sections so it looks natural. the lines come out as thin as the hairs on your brows.