drugstore.com
welcome: sign in|account|help
2 Sites 1 Bag
0 items $0.00checkout

drugstore.com

drugstore.com

e.l.f. professional Regular & Waterproof Mascara, Noire 1 ea

 
our price: $1.49
in stock

Hidden Tab
Hidden Tab
Hidden Tab
 

REVIEW SNAPSHOT®

by PowerReviews
e.l.f. professional Regular & Waterproof Mascara, Noire, 1 ea
 
2.2

(based on 39 reviews)

Ratings Distribution

  • 5 Stars

     

    (6)

  • 4 Stars

     

    (4)

  • 3 Stars

     

    (2)

  • 2 Stars

     

    (7)

  • 1 Stars

     

    (20)

31%

of respondents would recommend this to a friend.

Pros

  • Easy to apply (6)
  • Easy removal (5)
  • Good colors (3)

Cons

    Best Uses

    • Everyday (4)
    • Travel (3)
      • Reviewer Profile:
      • Classic style (6), Natural style (3), Trendy style (3)

    Most Liked Positive Review

     

    what a deal!

    I got this for my daughter because she is a wake border, she loves it and you can't beat the great price!!

    I got this for my daughter because she is a wake border, she loves it and you can't beat the great price!!

    VS

    Most Liked Negative Review

     

    Are you feeling lucky????

    Got one for me and one for a friend. Mine was fine, but my friends arrived already dried out! Seems to be the luck of the draw with this mascara. If you get ...Read complete review

    Got one for me and one for a friend. Mine was fine, but my friends arrived already dried out! Seems to be the luck of the draw with this mascara. If you get one not dried out, its a great mascara. I've used it about 3 weeks so far with no problems. Definitely a risk to buy it as there does not seem to be any quality assurance with this product.

    Reviewed by 39 customers

    Sort by

    Displaying reviews 21-30

    Back to top

    « Previous | Next »

    (1 of 1 customers found this review helpful)

     
    3.0

    Why only 3 stars? Well I ...

    By Jacqueline

    from Undisclosed

    See all my reviews

    Comments about e.l.f. professional Regular & Waterproof Mascara, Noire, 1 ea:

    Why only 3 stars? Well I only use waterproof mascara. So the other half of the tube is completely useless. I wish they'd figure out how to get rid of the clumps I get at times. NOT always, but at times it does give me that. I haven't tried any mascara that hasn't done that though. If they could just make one tube to be waterproof and another regular, that would be GREAT!

     
    3.0

    I'm not sure how I feel ...

    By Elisabeth

    from Saint Louis, MO

    See all my reviews

    Comments about e.l.f. professional Regular & Waterproof Mascara, Noire, 1 ea:

    I'm not sure how I feel about this product. I bought it a while back when e.l.f. first launched, and I hated it. It smelled bad and dried up, left my lashes clumpy, etc... I bought it again recently (there's a new color--brown), and the mascara has changed. It smells like rose water (even though that is not an ingredient) and applies a lot easier. It also stays put and washes off much easier. So... if you've had any bad experiences with it in the past, I suggest going to eyeslipsface.com and buying it directly from them. I only gave it 3 stars because like I said, I'm not sure how I feel about it, but the formula seems much better now.

     
    4.0

    I'm giving this product a ...

    By Zay

    from Undisclosed

    See all my reviews

    Comments about e.l.f. professional Regular & Waterproof Mascara, Noire, 1 ea:

    I'm giving this product a 4 star rating because the regular side of this mascara is useless. I was a bit skeptical because of the other reviews but decided to give it a try because, hey, it's only a dollar. I was surprised and not dissapointed at all. I know how to apply mascara really good, therefore, it did not glup, no tarantula eyes here!!!! It lasts all day. Furthermore, if it does flake that means you apply waaaaaaaaaaay too much. I love this stuff, I would not use another. If you don't like the wand just change it, some wands can be better than this one, but I have no problems with the wand.

     
    1.0

    I've used other e.l.f. ...

    By Anonymous

    from Undisclosed

    Comments about e.l.f. professional Regular & Waterproof Mascara, Noire, 1 ea:

    I've used other e.l.f. products, and was satisfied until now. This was horrible. The waterproof side stinks (literally)! I thought it was spoiled. The regular side made my lashes clump together and hard to separate. It was difficult to take off, and I lost a lot of lashes in the process.

     
    1.0

    Really wanted to like ...

    By Susan H

    from New York, NY

    See all my reviews

    Comments about e.l.f. professional Regular & Waterproof Mascara, Noire, 1 ea:

    Really wanted to like this product, since I prefer "cruelty free" products, but this is THE WORST mascara I've ever used.

     
    1.0

    Terrible! I have been ...

    By Anonymous

    from Undisclosed

    See all my reviews

    Comments about e.l.f. professional Regular & Waterproof Mascara, Noire, 1 ea:

    Terrible! I have been pleased with other e.l.f. products. But the mascara was a huge disappointment. Was flaking off as soon as it was dry.

     
    1.0

    Maybe I just got an old ...

    By Cassondra

    from Woodstock, GA

    See all my reviews

    Comments about e.l.f. professional Regular & Waterproof Mascara, Noire, 1 ea:

    Maybe I just got an old tube, but this is the most dried out clumpy mascara I've ever had. The waterproof end is liquid enough to use, but smells awful. Could it have been contaminated by something? And the regular end is completely unuseable. Oh well.

    (1 of 1 customers found this review helpful)

     
    4.0

    I have to admit I was ...

    By Aihui Wang

    from Undisclosed

    See all my reviews

    Comments about e.l.f. professional Regular & Waterproof Mascara, Noire, 1 ea:

    I have to admit I was skeptical to try out e.l.f. products, since I've had such bad experiences with most of them--like eyeshadows. When I first opened it, it smelled strange, a little like factory smell, but thankfully, it has worn off after 1-2 applications. The mascara gives a nice definition and coats my lashes perfectly. the only negative part is that the waterproof mascara takes quite a while to remove, while the regular mascara removes easily when it comes into contact with water, meaning you'll have to cover your eyes when it's raining outside!

     
    1.0

    Something is definitely ...

    By Anonymous

    from Undisclosed

    See all my reviews

    Comments about e.l.f. professional Regular & Waterproof Mascara, Noire, 1 ea:

    Something is definitely wrong with the waterproof mascara in this 2-in-one product. It smells like rotting garbage!! Absolutely HORRIBLE! I noticed it the very first time I used it. I wonder if it was contaminated with bacteria when it was put into the tube.

     
    5.0

    I didn't expect much for ...

    By Kathy w

    from Woodbridge, VA

    See all my reviews

    Comments about e.l.f. professional Regular & Waterproof Mascara, Noire, 1 ea:

    I didn't expect much for the price, but I got it to try. I've had great luck with it. The waterproof side wears all day long for me, whereas more expensive lines don't last as long. I am buying more tonight.

    Displaying reviews 21-30

    Back to top

    « Previous | Next »

    related products
    CoverGirl Professional Waterproof All In One Mascara, Very Black
    Straight Brush, Waterproof, Smudgeproof. Volume + Length + Separation. Thickens, lengthens ...
    L'Oreal Paris Studio Secrets Pro Extra Volume Collagen Hydra
    12x More Impact Instantly Extreme Volume Clump free Flake free ...
    ADVERTISEMENT
    ADVERTISEMENT