Comments about L'Oreal Pencil Perfect Eyeliner, Carbon Black 190, .01 oz:

this eyeliner smeared onto my upper eyelid before I even left the bathroom. I tried it again and it definitely did not stay in place for long.

Comments about L'Oreal Pencil Perfect Eyeliner, Carbon Black 190, .01 oz:

I wore this two days in a row. I didn't even rub my eyes and within a couple of hours, I looked like one of the lingerie football players from the L.A. Temptations! I even used the Mac finishing spray that "freezes" your makeup and it still ran/smeared!

My favorite eyeliner was discontinued and I haven't been able to find one to replace it yet!

Comments about L'Oreal Pencil Perfect Eyeliner, Carbon Black 190, .01 oz:

I have used this product every day for several years. I often have trouble applying other eyeliners, but this one goes on easily. The only issue I have with it is, you have to be very careful with the cap because it breaks easily and will mash down on the pencil.

Yes, it's a softer pencil than most. Yes, it can smudge if you overdo it. But overall, it's the best eyeliner I have ever used.

Comments about L'Oreal Pencil Perfect Eyeliner, Carbon Black 190, .01 oz:

I like soft liners, but this is too soft, therefore not easy to apply. Too bad because, when they work well, mechanical pencils are my favorite liner -- I can't imagine why everyone doesn't love them. Also, the liner doesn't advance easily when the mechanism is turned. Good idea, but this misses the mark. (For giving up the sharpener, though, I still might use it again.)

Comments about L'Oreal Pencil Perfect Eyeliner, Carbon Black 190, .01 oz:

I've used this eyeliner in the past before it was "improved" and I loved it! It would go on easy and stay on all day. But after I ran out, I bought another eyeliner pencil, same color, same brand, but it said improved and that it glides on easier. This stuff smears and smudges without me even touching my eyes. I've been wearing eyeliner for about 20 yrs. and have never bought anything this bad. After a couple of hours I swear I look like a raccoon. Now I have to find a different brand and go buy it and throw this messy one away.

Comments about L'Oreal Pencil Perfect Eyeliner, Carbon Black 190, .01 oz:

I don't usually write reviews in here, but I felt that I had to let you know on this one- it's horrible! such a mess.. difficult to apply to get that perfectly fine nice line, smudges, fades, you name it.. and I am like a pro at applying eyeliner. It's my number one make-up must! I work 9-5pm and have graduate night classes till 9pm. It definetely fails the time test!
Maybe it;s just me.. I see for some ppl it works and they love it.. but I had quite a few different eyeliners before and this one is the worst by far.

Comments about L'Oreal Pencil Perfect Eyeliner, Carbon Black 190, .01 oz:

Now I just LOVE this liner. I bought a stick like a year ago at [@] and loved it! but since then I haven't been able to find it anywhere. I was very excited when it was here:)

Comments about L'Oreal Pencil Perfect Eyeliner, Carbon Black 190, .01 oz:

I had to simply STOP using this. Everyday around lunch I would have black all under my eyes- not where I wanted it. This was not from my mascara. Once I stopped using this eyeliner, it stopped. I wan't rubbing my eyes- it just smudged and smeared. Since we live overseas, I am now having to buy eyeliner online because I refuse to wear it any longer.

Comments about L'Oreal Pencil Perfect Eyeliner, Carbon Black 190, .01 oz:

I LOVE this product! It's the best pencil I ever had!!!