Comments about Maybelline Line Works Ultra Ultra-Liner Liquid Waterproof Liquid Liner, Black, .25 fl oz:

The only good things I can say about it are the brush is thin and the product goes on easily. HOWEVER - less than two hours after putting it on, it is flaking and then it starts peeling off in chunks. I do not put a lot on, and only one layer. I've given it a couple tries, and every time it starts to flake within a couple hours. It's going in the garbage.

Comments about Maybelline Line Works Ultra Ultra-Liner Liquid Waterproof Liquid Liner, Black, .25 fl oz:

it flakes off and doesn't last long on eyelids

Comments about Maybelline Line Works Ultra Ultra-Liner Liquid Waterproof Liquid Liner, Black, .25 fl oz:

I used to use this product exclusively for years, though over the last few they must have changed the foundational make-up of the product because there is no need to wash it off. You can just peel off the remaining residue at the end of the day. And applying over old doesn't work either. Very sad!

Comments about Maybelline Line Works Ultra Ultra-Liner Liquid Waterproof Liquid Liner, Black, .25 fl oz:

I wanted a good liquid eyeliner to make a cat eye look, this sucked!! I put it on and at first I was happy then a half hour later it started to flake!! It would just come off right after it was dry.. I would not recommend this for nothing!!!

Comments about Maybelline Line Works Ultra Ultra-Liner Liquid Waterproof Liquid Liner, Black, .25 fl oz:

This is a great formula - better than any other I've tried, and trust me, I've tried them all! The wand makes a nice, clean line. If you go lightly, it's really thin, and with a heavier application it goes on that way too. (day/night applications). I've actually started top-coating my (waterproof) mascara with the eyeliner wand because it seals it (no running or smudging, even when I'm at the beach, sweating in the hot sun and playing in the water. I put it on every morning and then forget about it for the rest of the day (great when going to work). I wish they made a mascara in the exact same formula. The downside is that i need to use baby oil to remove it, and it takes a couple applications and gentle rubbing to get it all off. That said, it's totally worth the extra patience. I've even slept in this eyeliner and it looked fine in the morning. I absolutely recommend this.

Comments about Maybelline Line Works Ultra Ultra-Liner Liquid Waterproof Liquid Liner, Black, .25 fl oz:

Having asian eyes, It's hard to find good eye products including eyeliners. The asian monolid quickly smudges liner on the top lid because skin constantly rubs against it, more water touches the lash line also. This product is very nice and the best I've used because it stays on ALL DAY for me, and I usually have a harder situation with eyeliners. Taking the liner off isn't hard and the color is an amazing pigmented dark black! The applicator is also nice and the lines are easy to shape. There seems to be alot of product in the container also.

Comments about Maybelline Line Works Ultra Ultra-Liner Liquid Waterproof Liquid Liner, Black, .25 fl oz:

I have been using this eyeliner for years! It's my favorite and doesn't leave the undereye blackness that others do.

Comments about Maybelline Line Works Ultra Ultra-Liner Liquid Waterproof Liquid Liner, Black, .25 fl oz:

This is not the eyeliner for people who look to create thin lines. Since the application is a brush tip, it is easier to create thicker lines. The only good part is that it stays all day and it doesn't smudge. But the application is not smooth at all, it flakes, and it takes forever to remove. Will not buy again.

Comments about Maybelline Line Works Ultra Ultra-Liner Liquid Waterproof Liquid Liner, Black, .25 fl oz:

I use this product every day. It last all day long and looks good the whole day. Never have to retouch.

Comments about Maybelline Line Works Ultra Ultra-Liner Liquid Waterproof Liquid Liner, Black, .25 fl oz:

I use this liner everyday and love it because of the fine brush that gives me control over where it is applied and a smooth continous stroke. The brush is fine so no clumps or messy application. I look for this product and will not use anything else .