Comments about Physicians Formula Shimmer Strips Custom Eye Enhancing Eyeliner Trio, Nude Eyes, 1 set:
First note that, though I have tried out the black and dark brown shaded eyeliners that come in this trio, I really only use the Champagne shade (the lightest one).
Here's my short and not-the-most-educated review of the black shade: it's a rich, beautiful black, but it's a little soft and smudges super easily. Here's my short and not-the-most-educated review of the brown shade: brown is a little too dark for me, and it also smudges easily.
Now let me review the one I know all about: the champagne shade. Though it also smudges easily, that's not a problem because it's so light on my fair/medium/olive skin (you can't tell). It's got a perfect light grey/brown hue, and adds a very subtle bit of life to my eyes. I imperfectly outline my entire eye with it (emphasis in the corners) and then smudge it a little with my index finger. It adds a shimmer (more natural), not a sparkle (more Broadway or Disney Chanel), which I like.
I just wish they sold the champagne shade alone so I would be paying for three eyeliners when I only use one. But it's worth the few extra bucks.
Bottom Line Yes, I would recommend this to a friend