Comments about Prestige Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil, Black, .05 oz:

Only worked well the first few times I used it. Threw it in the trash!

Comments about Prestige Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil, Black, .05 oz:

I was trying to find a less expensive eyeliner for lining under the eyes than Bobbi Brown and MAC and having to use a waterproof shellac. I like Prestige eyebrow pencil and thought I'd give the Prestige eyeliner a try. It is waterproof in that when you apply and make mistakes, you cannot rub it off unless you remove with heavy-duty waterproof eye makeup remover. But you need to rub hard and this irritates and reddens your skin around the delicate eye area, which is obviously not what you want. Then the eyeliner runs after 20 minutes of walking outdoors and it wasn't even hot or humid out. I experimented with this three times, second and third time I didn't even use remover to wipe off excess liner and it still made me look like raccoon eyes. I'm sticking with my other eyeliners.

Comments about Prestige Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil, Black, .05 oz:

Waterproof eyeliners usually either make my eyes tear, or they just run and smudge. This is really the best I have tried - nice smooth bold color and stays on. It does smudge a bit at the corners, but not as much as others. I went swimming with it and it was still on (used on lower lash line), and did not give me racoon eyes.

Comments about Prestige Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil, Black, .05 oz:

I love this product, I use Liquid liners most of the time but this really does what It says. its very easy to apply and can be worn several different ways! One of the best pencils I have had in a long time

Comments about Prestige Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil, Black, .05 oz:

Whatever the opposite of "glides" is, that's how this eyeliner goes on. Even with repeated applications, there is no way to get a solid look. It feels waxy & it won't adhere to the eyelids. Therefore, it doesn't appear as black, more like a spotchy gray. A complete waste of money.

Comments about Prestige Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil, Black, .05 oz:

Really good product a little fading and running but I have yet to find an eyeliner that doesn't. All in all one of the best I've tried.