I use this mascara every day. I have oily skin & am prone to watery eyes. This mascara never smuges or runs. I take it off at night with baby oil.

I like it because it does not smudge or come off if you rub your eyes. It does not come off with water.

Love the curved brush..have used this mascara for years..it never comes off...

This is the only mascara I have found that I like. I have used it for over 20 years. This product doesn't flake or smudge, and since I wear contacts that is important. Some others I have tried that are waterproof tend to flake and not last as long.

I've been using this stuff for years along with its companion remover which is the only way I've found to remove it. The biggest Con I know is how difficult it is to remove from your skin after you put it on and then, blink. You've got to get it fast. I joke that one could swim the English Channel in this stuff.

It is truly Marathon. Put it on once and it stays on and on and on. I've used this mascara for over 10 years and I promise you there is nothing like it. Others say water-proof, but still FLAKE. Marathon does NOT flake.To me, that's more important than all the fancy stuff they come out with just to trick us into a purchase. .(one funny thing..My daughter was having a baby 12 years ago and the morning of the day she went to the hospital she used this product because she said she didn't want her mascara running all over her face) She was right.It did not. This is a great product. Try it, you won't be sorry. LINDA JACKSON

i don't know why~ i purchase a 400 black negro noir (that's what it says on the cover) but the color seems....brown...to me~ i mean it's definitely not dark enough for my taste and after i apply it i feel like i have nothing on it's good to have a natural look but ...a little bit too natural looking??? also...it's hard to remove~ now i'm going back to my clinique mascara~

I have thin lashes that fall very easily after curling. This is the only mascara that gives me lashes a lift-which holds up all day.

Love this mascara -- apparently, they are taking it off the market because I can no longer find it in stores. The "replacement" mascaras CoverGirl has come out with smudge and smear under my eyes.

Yes this product stays on- way too long. Even with a couple of different makeup removers, I couldn't get it all off. I was left with sore eyelids from all the rubbing and clumpy lashes. I threw it away after only a few days.