I used this when I ran out of my CG Perfect Point Plus and it was very hard to get used to because these eyeliners that you have to sharpen drive me crazy! also, everytime I went to use it on my lower lash line, my eyeshadow, which is very highly pigmented because it's MAC, would get all over the tip, so I would have to stop and wipe it off before I could finish lining just one eye, it was insane! taking a lighter to it would've helped it work much better, except for the fact that, unfortunately, everytime I did my makeup, I didn't have any of my lighters on me. then, THEN, the thing that bothered me the most about this eyeliner was that since there were 2 different caps for each end, when it was nearing the end, I couldn't even finish it off and sharpen it down anymore because I couldn't cap it without the caps running into each other and I absolutely hate wasting. after being freshly sharpened, though, this eyeliner worked pretty good, that's why I gave it 3 stars. if I had to buy it or go without eyeliner, I'd settle for it, again.

I LOVE these CoverGirl liners! I've been searching for the perfect liners that won't break the bank! I was, before, spending about half of my hourly wage on just one liner, I tried this because it was cheaper than the rest of the liners. Turns out cheap is good for this liner. The one thing is (probably is my makeup remover) it's a bit tough to get rid of, but again, it MUST be my remover. but since it's good with other products, this is why this gets four stars. I think you should get this!!!

Overall great product for the price, goes on very smooth and lasts all day, another bonus is the smudger at the end which is great for smokey eyes. If you havent yet give it a try!

This pencil was great until I started having a reaction to it. I would definately keep using it if my eyes didn't burn when I used it.

I do NOT understand the rave reviews for this product. I'm usually very good with eyeliner, but this one was possibly THE worst I've EVER tried. I gave it 2 stars because it is small, has a blender, and is ok for my upper lashes. But it smudges, the blender does nothing (it just removes product so that it turns sort of grey), it's hard to sharpen, it clumps together on my lower lashes (I don't know HOW it clumps, but it does), and is not creamy enough. Absolutely horrible, never buy this if you are into good quality!!! I understand that for some people, this is very good, this is WAY below par.

I really like this eyeliner. It works great, and I also like the "smudging" device at the other end. I highly recommend this product.

This is a great pencil. It has a soft texture and blends well for a smoky effect. The blending side comes in handy. It is small in size which makes it perfect for the makeup bag. I would buy this again.

I love this eyeliner! Next time I buy it I will get it in brown because the black is a little too dark for my eyes. Overall, it's a great product.