This is the best eye makeup remover I've ever used. Its just like Mary Kay's version but less expensive and easier to purchase. I wear contacts and waterproof mascara and this does the trick. My eyes are very sensitive and all other removers I've tried are painful.

This stuff removes your makeup - all of it, in a snap!!! No more waking up in the am looking like a raccoon!!! Love it!

Love this product! Leaves eyes moisturized, does not sting or burn, and takes off makeup in a snap

This is an excellent eye-makeup remover. I didn't give it 5 stars just because it takes a little bit of effort to remove all traces of eye makeup. This is different from other removers I used in that it doesn't sting my eyes. Even Clinique has stung my eyes and it's almost 3x the price of this. I'm on my second bottle and I can see myself buying a 3rd bottle. Good stuff, good price.

Just so-so. It requires more work than it should to dissolve waterproof mascara.

My eyelashes are really hard to remove mascara from. Even after using other mascara removers it literally would take three days of washing my face to remove mascara. This is the first eye make-up remover ever that removed all of the mascara from my eyelashes on the first try. It didn't make the corners of my eyes dry and itchy like every other eye make-up removers have done.

Removes even waterproof mascara easily. Safe for contact lens wearers, like me. Neutrogena is a solid company, always delivers good quality products.

Definitely the best stuff ever! I find it extremely effective if you dab a little bit of water on your eyes first, then saturate a thin cotton sheet with the remover, final gently press on the closed eyelid for a few seconds and rub it slowly. I guarantee you everything comes right off in seconds. It's so good I even use it to remove fake eye lashes!!!

This is the best eye makeup remover! I've tried several kinds, and they are all too harsh and burn my eyes or my skin. Neutrogena doesn't burn my skin and takes off all of my eye makeup. I LOVE THIS PRODUCT!

I purchased this product one day when I couldn't find my usual eye makeup remover by Nivea. Nivea is still my favorite, but this one wasn't bad. It is an oil-based remover, but somehow manages to not leave an overly oily residue on your eyes. It is gentle, and does a thorough job without a whole lot of rubbing, but again - it does require more rubbing and tugging at my eyes than does the Nivea brand. I did find that it merely smears the makeup around unless I wet my face first - not a big deal, but something I don't have to do with the Nivea product, so it took me a while to figure it out. All in all Neutrogena has a decent product here, but it places a distant second to my all-time favorite, Nivea!