I love these eyeliners by Max Factor! The only reason this is four stars is that I wish they had more color options for liners, like silver and greens, but oh well. These go on easily, I like applying twice.I also wish they were like the cheapies eyeliners that I can get (like Milani easyliners) on my working salary, these liners are a splurge, so cheap[$] ones are great for me. Since I have a low-wage job, I get one every once in a while. Still, good liners.

I like it....nice eyeliner.

I'm picky - I like a liner that smudges nicely for a natural look, but it also has to stay on the whole day. And, I don't want to have to sharpen it like a pencil. This eyeliner has it all. Stays on better than Cover Girl's Perfect Point Plus. I'll stick with this one.