Overall this is the best eyeliner at great price. Goes on smooth, and long wearing.It doesn;t smudge or run, and washes off easily with cleanser and water. I do wish the black was a little more black. And it held a point a little better, still I find as long as I keep the sharpener clean, I can get a fresh point anytime.

***I ONLY USE THIS EYELINER...IT GOES ON NICE...NO SHARPENING REQUIRED...STAYS ON ALL DAY TILL I TAKE IT OFF WITH RIMMEL EYE MAKE-UP REMOVER...I ALSO LIKE THAT IT IS MADE IN ITALY....ITS PERFECT!

Goes on evenly and smooth, I also love the sharpener. Great eyeliner.

Goes on nicely. Stays on pretty good too.

stays on through most of the day. doesn't smudge very much. washes off easily. a good product, would buy again especially if on sale. i wish the "onyx" was a darker shade of black.

I have never previously found an eyeliner that didn't smudge. I bought this based on a review from a buyer who was deployed to Iraq and said it didn't smudge. She was right and I am pleased with the product.

I've tried a gazillion eyeliners over the years and this is the ONLY one that doesn't smudge.

Gave me raccoon eyes; I tried the brown color and found it didn't go on that smoothly or blend well, but I find that's common with all brown liners in general

I...LOVE...this eyeliner! It is the best eyeliner I have ever used in my life. I've tried eyeliners from Clinque, Chanel, and tried a bunch of stuff from Sephora, but this seriously is the best. I'm in the army and in Iraq and I use this. I go to the pool, gym, out on missions wearing this eyeliner. It stays on for hours and hours and doesn't even smudge. I absolutely love this and I have like a year's supply of this because I'm not going to stop wearing eyeliner just because I'm in Iraq! I still want to look good no matter where I am, or whatever I'm doing.