I think this particular eyeliner is the best one yet. I have tried other brands and sometimes the tip of the liner is so hard, its difficult to apply. This eyeliner stays on very well, is inexpensive compared to those you find in department stores and it is easy to apply.

I purchased this looking for a really dramatic eyeliner I could do a lot with, and as my first liquid liner. I'm usually not happy with makeup purchases, but I love this one! I'm so happy I bought it, and at around $8, it's not badly priced at all.Having never used liquid liner before, I'm surprised by how easy it is. The key is to be really gentle until you know how much you want to apply and what pressure you should use. This is fantastic for creating very precise lines; I was able to do a full Egyptian style cats eye including inside corner with no problem at all.Another thing that was surprising was how easy it was to remove. I was able to take mine off with just water and tissues, and it didn't leave the smudgy, smokey leftovers you often get with other liners that make it look like you haven't slept. Very nice.Only thing I'd have to mention it is that it IS an extremely dark black, like the color you'd get from a permanent marker, so make sure this color is okay with your skintone and features first. Otherwise it may look far too strong or overpowering. Would definitely work best with a mascara, as even my dark brown eyelashes weren't anywhere near a match for this liner in color.

I am new to liquid eyeliner and thought that maybe a felt tip would be easier than the brush normal liquid liners come with. Well although it did take some practice I am now able to apply my eyeliner with the felt tip and love it way better tha pencil. I like doing a thin line close to the lash line on the top only and it looks great. Looks so natural and really widens and brightens my eyes. With the contrast of my brown eyes and the black liner, my eyes really stand out, before they just looked blah, but now I see how beautiful my brown eyes really are. Easily comes off with Loreal eye makeup remover. Love this.

I've tried a lot of liquid eyeliners, and this is easily my favorite. I use it practically every day (but I do not have sensitive skin or sensitive eyes). Its greatest attribute is its felt applicator -- Brushes can occasionally leave stray marks, but having a felt applicator is like using a marker. As with all liquid eyeliners, this product requires both a steady hand and enough time to dry. The eyeliner, aside from the applicator, is rich and deep, and it does not fade throughout the day. If applied to an area that creases often during the day (e.g. the outer corners of the eyes), the eyeliner creases slightly, but I don't know what product can claim not to. I don't think I'll ever find a better liquid eyeliner.

I have tried eyeliners from nearly every cosmetics manufacturer - from Urban Decay to MAC to Revlon. This is the only one I LOVE! It lasts all day until I go to bed at night. The outer corners of my eyes may smudge a tad during the day, but the line itself doesn't budge. It's not labeled as waterproof, but this is one of the few that doesn't disappear if I cry. It's the best liner with the longest staying power out there as far as I'm concerned.

I absolutely love this eyeliner. I use it every day, and it's great. Its only downfall is that it smudges A BIT, and doesn't last on the bottom last line, but what does last down there? I love it, and it doesn't smudge much, I mean a tiny, tiny bit in the corners of the eyes. It lasts all day though, and doesn't crack or fade.