I love this liner- it's my absolute favorite! You have to have a brush though- I personally have 2 brushes, a thin, detail one, and a wider, flat one. I use the wider, flat one for everyday use, to apply the liner in my lash line, and the thin brush if I want to create a smooth line above the lash line.It stays on all day, no smudging unles you really rub hard, and even then it doesn't really smear- it just gets on your fingers. I have found that some makeup removers work on this liner and others don't, so if you have trouble removing it all the way, try another remover. Water won't wash it away. I even left it on a few times in the pool; it barely moved at all!Another thing I like about it is that it isn't shiny- like liquid liners- instead it has a matte finish and goes on just as smooth. I doesn't flake either. You can also smudge it a little before it dries, right after applying, to get softer edges.Be careful not to leave the lid off too long or it will dry ot and be pretty much useless! I also wish that beauty.com sold this liner in black, so I don't have to go to [...] for it. The dark brown is pretty dark though- to the point that its actually pretty hard to tell that it isn't black- unless you have black lashes or mascara.

Great eyeliner, easy to use.

This is so much better than using liquid, as long as you have the right brush. I own a MAC eyeliner brush so I already knew how to apply this. But it is smooth, and easy to layer for a lighter or darker line. I didn't expect that as the color looks pretty standard brown iin the pot. It's not as dark brown as I expected , so if you need a darker brown, don't get this one!