I've been using this eyeliner for 2 years now, I always keep at least 2 just in case if I'm out of it. It's very smooth and easy to apply, if you are kinda girl love to draw it sharp to the end, it's a perfect eyeliner for you. But, this smudges REALLY BAD if you use under eyes, it doesnt last not even an hour and start to look pretty bad. I'd rather use a different waterproof eyeliner for my underline.

This item was bought for my 17 year old daughter. She uses it everyday, under the lower lashes. She said that it just glides on very smoothly, and stays in place until she takes it off. The color is perfect, just how it is shown on Drugstore.com. She says that she would like to stick to this color and brand the next time I put an order in, and SHE IS PICKY!

I had such high hopes for this based on other reviews. It just wants to move around and give me raccoon eyes! I've since moved on to Maybelline Line Express, which has better staying power.

I love this eye pencil. It goes on easy and stays on until I am ready to take it off.

I like this product,, I have used more expensive eyeliners and have been disappointed, so expensive for sure isn't always better,, I like that it goes on without tugging the eye and gives the darkness that I like. The only negative is that it does creases in the eye.

I love it and have used this forever. You can always get a perfect line from this.

I love this product. It goes on easily and gives me the look I want.

This eyeliner makes my eyes look great. It goes on smooth and is not too dramatic. The only thing bad about it is that it fades throughout the day so you have to reapply.

I've had so many problems with this eyeliner and used it to the very last broken off bit and couldn't wait to get rid of it. The tip kept breaking off, so I couldn't have a point at the end, but rather a serrated edge. Everyday the liner would jump from right above my eyelashes--where I put it in the morning--and find its way to my eyelid so I had a little frown right under my eyebrows. That totally wasn't the look I was going for.

I love this liner; it goes on so smooth. Some liners irritate my eye and make it feel raw because they aren't smooth enough. The only downside to this eye liner is that it smudges and runs a little bit.