This is the worst mascara I have ever tried. I could not wait to write a review on it, I feel that strongly about it. It takes forever to dry so it gets all over your eyes. It is runny and thin. It did not do a single thing for my lashes. It is like putting black water on them.

doesnt catch all the lashes... I have lighter ones & it was difficult to cover all of them to the base of the lash. Also flakes off easily

First, I want to start out by describing what this mascara does. For me, I only saw results with the length and separation of my lashes. There was absolutely no volume or curl produced. However, since I have naturally short, thick and curly lashes, this mascara was perfect for my needs. With only two coats I can have very long lashes. Unlike the other reviewers, I had no problems with flaking of smudging but this may be due to my different needs. The look can be either natural or glamorous depending on the other makeup applied. There are only a few drawbacks. First, the mascara seems to dry up quickly, making it necessary to spend more time applying, or investing in a new mascara. Also, there is a slight smell that seems common with Maybelline mascaras; the smell does not bother me, but it may bother others. Overall, this was the perfect lengthening mascara with very few drawbacks.

Not much to say...the cons tell all...if it didn't fall off in flakes shortly after applying the look would be perfect. Instead, beware & look closely in the mirror to keep cleaning off the debris under your eyes. Ouch!

This is the worst mascara I've ever tried. It doesn't go on easily and later there are smudges around my eyes and flakes all over under my eyes and on my cheeks. I have absolutely nothing positive to say about this mascara. I would have given it no stars but that wasn't an option.

Made my lashes really stand out. Lengthens as promised. Flaked after several hours of wear. I like it a lot more than I thought I would!

I was pleasantly surprised by this mascara. I had been using Merle Norman's Luxiva mascara but it ran out on me right before going out last night. I went up and bought this as a "need this now" decision and was actually impressed. I LOVE the way the brush is... it's very long which makes it easier to apply. I noticed that shorter brushes, I tended to hit my temple or the upper part of my cheek with the mascara when in a hurry. This is nice and long so I can hold it further from my skin. I have very thin lashes and this makes my lashes POP. People actually noticed and asked what mascara I use.

I'm still looking for that patent shine. This mascara is not all that great. It does nothing amazing to me. My lashes are naturally long and it didn't give my lashes any volume, length, or definition.

Absolutely love this mascara! My lashes haven't looked this great in years! Will never use anything else!

THE CHEAPER VERSION OF DIORSHOW!!! I bought it for[$] at [...]!! This is amazing! After being very disappointed by the Colossal Volume Express mascara, this one has really redeemed Maybelline! This mascara lengthens extremely well. It is also very, very black. It separates my lashes very well, and does not clump. As far as volume, I don't think this mascara is advertised as volumizing, but my lashes need length more than they need volume. You will be amazed at the length and definition you have after just two coats. I have been skeptical about cheap mascaras, so I have been using Diorshow for quite some time, but Maybelline Lash Stiletto is the only other mascara I have tried that matches the length and definition that Diorshow gives me. IF YOU CURRENTLY USE DIORSHOW, TRY THIS MASCARA!!