i would actually give it 0 stars. i've used two pads. the first one was horrible, wayyy to oily, and it left me feeling dirty and greasy. then i thought, maybe i was overreacting, so i tried it a second time. not only did it leave my eye just as greasy and horrible but my eye got this weird redness and burning sensation. I'm throwing it away, ladies, dont buy this horrible product, its a rip-off.

I have used this eye makeup remover for at least 25 years and it is the ONLY makeup remover I will ever use. I tried Almay's non-oily version for a little while last year when I couldn't find this one, but I hated the other one because I had to tug at my skin too much to get the makeup off! I have gotten plenty of comments on how young I look--and I know this product has been a major contributor to the lack of wrinkles around my eyes (I'm 58). I also use this to remove some of the longer-lasting lipsticks when remnants remain at the end of the day.

Terrible product, especially for teenagers! These honestly feel as though someone took a cotton pad, dipped it in olive oil, then put it in a container and sold it as eye makeup remover. I broke out like crazy, and I don't even have very bad skin. This product may be good for older people who like oil, but try to find another product!

The only WORKING makeup remover which actually removes mascara without a hassle. All other types, even Almay's non-oily product, don't remove anything, they just smudge it around. Also, in spite of its name, this remover is not so awfully oily, just right to dissolve the makeup without major workout on the eyelid.

Way too oily. I'm throwing the package away! The pads by e.l.f. are much better, and less expensive.

I've been using these for years and years in order to remove my waterproof mascara (regular mascara does not work for me). I love these, even if they ARE oily (and I'm 38 with no wrinkles, so maybe the oiliness of this product has helped?). I wash my entire face after I use these, so oil residue has never been a problem. I'll probably use these forever.

This is the worst makeup remover I have ever used! It is so oily, it not only leaves oil all over your eyes, but on your hands as well. It stings my eyes and leaves my vision blurry, and I'm left trying to remove the makeup remover in the end. Such a hassle, not worth it!

I love this product so much by after tried it once! Yes, it's greasy with no doubt because it's the "moisturizing" type! So you may can choose the "oil-free" one according to your need. For me, this "moisturizing" one....its "oily" texture is the biggest advantage because it really can remove the waterproof mascara and lipstick effectively without tugging my eyelashes hardly, so it won't cause the wrinkles since it's delicate as moisturizing enough to use on the delicate eye skin. I neither feel it's too oily nor too dry. With the economy price, I think this product is simply "PERFECT"!

Works great to remove waterproof mascara and eyeliner with minimum tugging/pulling. I live in a humid climate, so waterproof makeup is a must, and these remove everything really well. Yes, they are oily, but I just remove my contacts first and keep my eyes fairly tightly shut. I find if I take a Boots facial cleaning cloth to my face afterward, there is very little residue from my eye makeup on there, and it takes care of the oily residue from the remover.

It's really oily! It's been 30 minutes since I washed my face and my vision is still blurry... I don't wear waterproof mascara, and that seems to be the problem. But this does feel like baby oil in my eyes.