I love these things. It removes waterproof mascara wonderfully. I do agree that it leaves an oily residue, but I wash my face afterwards and it's all gone so I don't see that as a problem. I tried the other kind of pads and they're worthless. I like these better as I don't have to work hard to remove the eye makeup and that's the whole point when working around delicate under eye tissue.

These makeup remover pads are the worst! It's like pouring mineral oil into your eyes! Leaves you with blurry vision and sticky, greasy eye lids. Then when your makeup is gone you are trying to remove all this gunk that's left! Do not waste your money on these. Get the "non-oily" pads instead, they are so much better!

This is a secret I have used for many years. Nothing works better on waterproof mascara.

I was very disappointed with this product. After using, I was not so much bothered by the residue, but my eyes were terribly irritated. Even after re-washing my face, the irritation remained. When I tried applying to a small area not directly in contact with my eye, I had the same reaction. I am surprised other reviewers did not have the same experience, as I do not have especially sensitive skin or eyes.

I love this product and have been using it for years. I wear waterproof mascara and this product is the only thing that will take it off without dragging and pulling the delicate skin around the eyes. Since I always wash my face after I remove my makeup the oily residue is not a problem - why would you remove your eye makeup without washing your face?!? After a few years I thought I would try non-oily removers, i.e. Almay and Maybelline, but they don't compare to this when it comes to removing waterproof mascara without damaging delicate skin around your eyes.

This product completely removed a new waterproof mascara I just got that wouldn't come off with the non-oily version or other makeup removers I tried. It makes your eyes a little oily after, so I wouldn't put my contacts in after use, but I think I'll just use this at night and then it won't be a problem.

This product works very well for me in the summer in the Midwest, but in the winter in the Midwest I find that the main ingredient (mineral oil) is very drying to my eye area and actually exaggerates the fine lines that I have. I recommend this product for use only in the summer or climates where the weather may be warmer year round.

I LOVE this product!! I've been a loyal user for approximately 10 years now. I use waterproof mascara and find this to be the easiest, most efficient, and most effective way to remove it. Yes, it leaves an oily film around your eyes, but this "film" doesn't harm my skin in any way. It's never caused pimples or any other skin condition (and my skin is VERY sensitive to breaking out, dryness, and rashes), so I really don't care about the oily film. I always wash my face with Cetaphil afterwards, so the oily film only remains around the delicate eye area. It works better than any other product I've tried (and I've tried A LOT), and the one-step process of the pre-moistened pads is perfect for my busy life style. Note: I found that these pads work MUCH better on waterproof mascara than the same product (called "Moisturizing Eye Make-up Remover Lotion") available in bottle form. I'm thrilled to have found this product at drugstore.com since it is often hard to find in local stores.

This product works especially well on waterproof mascara, you don't need to rub it off incessantly. It's slightly oily, but this is what makes it work so well. I usually just rinse it off with my usual face wash and I'm good to go.

This product is WAY too greasy. Removes eye makeup fairly well, but leaves a thick and oily residue that is hard to get off. The non-oily variety, however, is a MUST have.