I love this eye liner. Goes on and stays on well. The brush that comes with this works well, but is hard to handle because it's so tiny. You have to buy your own brush, but make sure it's a firm one for gel/cream eye liner. A soft one won't work.

i loved the cream eyeliner its easy to apply and lasts mostly all day unlike other that smudge but i did not like the brush its tooooo small and too sharp but other than the brush this product is pretty good!

I agree that this is difficult to apply (I am used to using liquid liners). It is very waxy; more solid than it should be. maybe a stiffer brush would work better? Also difficult to remove with make up remover. Once I got the hang of it, the color was good, but it was too much of a pain to remove, and so isn't worth it. This product contains parabens, which detracts from the fact that some of the ingredients are "organic."

Not easy to apply. It's more of a paste than a gel so it clumps as you drag the brush across the lid. As hard as I tried, I could not get a clean straight line and I have been working with gel and liquid liners for years.