I use this because I have dry eyes and use products to create tears. Mascaras that are not waterproof will run but this one doesn't. I remove it with and oil based remover and it seems to make my lashes more healthy.

Hard to find the color Dark Brown. Can always find it here.

This is the mascara I've bought for years at the store. New tubes contain very thick mascara that needs to be applied lightly. The tube from Drugstore contained thin, watery mascara that I spent time applying over and over until it does something. After a month of use, it is not worth my time and I'll have to buy more.

I have been using the washable mascara for many years for lashes. However, I purchased the waterproof mascara because I use it as a brow enhancer. It works perfectly, stays on and doesn't smudge especially through gym workouts, swimming, even showering, but it's easy to remove with soap or facial wash. I've tried other products, but returned to this. Can't be beat for the price and quality. I hope they don't discontinue Dark Brown Waterproof, as it's really difficult to find.

An excellent value! This is as effective and waterproof as anything out there. Note that "waterproof" does not mean "oil proof." If you have oily skin, as I do, I recommend you use this only on your top lashes, and then finish with a coat of the Maybelline Clear Mascara which acts as a wonderful sealant. Make sure you wipe off the clear mascara wand after each application, so you don't contaminate your clear mascara with the dark.

I bought this because I had always heard that this was one of the greatest mascaras ever, at least due to reviews on other websites. I used the tube up to avoid wasting it but I wouldn't purchase it again. It did make my lashes look a bit fuller, but not longer, and it definitely was not waterproof. In high humidity or very warm climates it sort of melts down underneath the eyes. I kept having to wipe away the black smears. There's no way it would hold up to a day at the beach if I couldn't even make it through the workday without it smearing around.

This mascara is fantastic for everyday; great colour, doesn't clump, and lengthens lashes while still being very natural looking. Excellent value.

This mascara hardly does anything but come off right away. It is not water-proof, it is not even blink-proof. It doesn't add any length or volume. This is one of the worst mascaras I've ever tried.