I have to warn you that I like "super waterproof mascara" I take my eye make-up with skin oil for sensitive skin so it comes out easily that way. I used to buy this mascara before, I could use it at the pool or anywhere and it stayed on with no smudges or runs at all. Maybelline took it off the market (I guess it was hard to remove for most eye makeup remover products) so I started using SKY HIGH CURVES from Maybelline and is my new favorite. When I placed my order my new favorite mascara was not available so when I found this one was back in the market I bought 2. Is not as good as it used to be, when you sweat there a tiiiiny bit of smudge which never happened before. I bet this is normal and they actually changed it due to consumers complaints, is just that with the way I take eye makeup off, this wasn't an issue. So for me is not as "super waterproof" as it used to be, but for all the girls/women that take off their makeup with eye makeup removers this would be a great choice for waterproof mascara.

Not bad for the price... not dramatic, but ok.

Doesn't smear or smudge.

I was disappointed. In general I like this product line and didn't have a bad experience before. But this one was too dry and hard to use.

Smudges and was not waterproof. On a hot day, I had black smudges under my eyes all day long. Forget this product if its humid outside.

this masacara lasts and lasts. Other top brands may go on thicker initially but they always flake. not this brand. You do have to apply 2-3 coats to get the thickness you want. Great lash is affordable and long lasting....no flaking

THIS MASCARA IS USUALLY VERY THICK, LASTS ME ABOUT 6 MONTH. DRUGSTORE'S WAS THIN, WATERY AND IS DRYING OUT AFTER ABOUT A MONTH'S USE.

This mascara has been around for a long time. There are fancier mascaras in fancier packages, but this is the best deal. It is waterproof, so I would recommend remover. I curl my eyelashes and this works the best, it stays on in water, but my lashes do come uncurled.

I try other products that reports their product doesn't clump or flake. But I always come back to Great Lash! Increadable formula, always can count on the result. My lashes are long but don't curl, and that it the only thing I wish Great Lash had.

The experts tell us that eye makeup should be replaced at least every three months. I wear mascara daily, and this is the best I have found, and the added bonus is that it is readily available and inexpensive. I prefer the waterproof because my lashes on the bottom will smudge against my skin. It comes off easily with any moisturizer or cold cream. Definitely a great product at a great price.