I love these! They work wonderfully for applying liquid makeup, and I had no problems with crumbling. They didn't feel rough at all - in fact, they were very smooth. I like that they're very inexpensive, so you can just throw them away when you're done. My only complaint is that they had a very strange smell, but it didn't interfere with their purpose, so it's fine. I definitely recommend these!

Very poor quality. Rough and porous. They absorb product like a rough sponge instead of making it possible to spread smoothly. Better to pay a tiny bit more and get something you can actually use for the intended purpose!

These are terrible. They have holes in them, and smell horrible.

I hate these sponges - for makeup. I stuff them under my innersoles to give me better arch support. That's about all they're good for.

These sponges are terrible! They are rough compared to other sponges I've tried. Pay a little extra and get something better.

I am a makeup artist and have been using these for the last 6 months or so. The price and quality are acceptable. I personally like the small size and the flexibility of the sponge. It has enough texture to apply the makeup and allow you to move it around when needed.

For inexpensive disposable sponges, these are great. They have a smooth texture and do a great job. Will continue to purchase them.

These sponges are really low quality! They have a rough texture (which does NOT help make the foundation go on smoothly), and they are quick to crumble. Almost every sponge I've tried has been better than this -- pass on this one.

I've been using these for over a year now. They are great. The quality is comparable to the higher priced sponges. They are textured and I like the grip this provides. It doesn't feel like it'll break apart but absolutely soft and flexible enough to get into your face crevices when applying makeup. I love that it comes in a bag. I can use one and toss them, great if you breakout or have occasional infections -- sanitary. I dampen them sometimes to give my liquid foundation a dewy look. I use them for makeup, eye creams, and occasionally as eye shadow applicators when I'm traveling. Great price and works like it should! Give it a try, it's a fab price!

I love these things and think that I get a great, even makeup application when using them. You can't go wrong for the price either.