I wear eye makeup. Subtle, but waterproof. This makeup remover manages to let me take it all off my face without a greasy feeling-even the waterproof stuff!

This product works great at removing my eye makeup but it is a little oilier than I would like. Not as oil free as stated.

Very effective, nonirritating

I've used this for years. Non-greasy, very effective, very gentle.

It works. Quickly removes makeup. Only thing is that sometimes it gets a little oily but that can easily be fixed with a face wash!

This product claims to remove waterproof mascara, that claim is a lie. I will admit it gets it off the very tip of the lash but that's it. I tried leaving it on for a few minutes before rubbing to see if it would help but it makes no difference. I don't even ware thick mascara, PATHETIC!

Maybe it's just me, but this product DOES NOT remove makeup well. I have to use it 2-3 times before I can get my eye makeup off, and I don't even use that much eye makeup! I end up pulling more than I like, which isn't good for the delicate skin around my eyes. The Lancme one I used to use is very clearly superior... I was hoping this one would replace that one because of the price, but I guess you get what you pay for.

This product does contain some type of oil. It left me feeling very greasy.

I love this product. Every other eye makeup remover makes the corners of my eyes dry and stinging for days. I made the mistake of using another eye makeup remover at a cosmetics counter after trying on mascara. My eyes became irritated right away. When I returned home I dabbed a little of this in corners of my eyes and it soothed the stinging that the other remover caused, plus it took off the rest of the mascara that the other remover left behind. This product rocks!

I found this product too oily (even though it says "oil free").