This stuff is amazing! No mascara is totally clump free! Its like impossible, but this is as close as you can get! It defines and lengthens my lashes and its nice and dark! It last all day too!

This stuff wasn't bad at all. I liked it, but I'm still looking for the perfect one. This stuff didn't clump all that much, and went on and came off easy. Maybe go back to using this one.

Tried other intense black waterproof mascaras just for variety, but keep coming back to this one, by far the best I've ever used. Excellent separation, deep color, extremely long-lasting, and minimal clumping (let's face it, NO mascara is entirely clump-free). To those who feel it's difficult to remove: I use a two-product system. First apply Neutrogena Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover, then rinse as directed and dry lightly. Then apply good ol' Pond's Cold Cream, massaging in gently. Tissue off, and mascara comes off perfectly. Sounds complicated, but worth the effort for mascara with a great look and real lasting power when you need it.

I really like this mascara because it's waterproof, and it stays a really long time. Didn't give my eyes any problem. I love it.

I actually thought this mascara worked wonderfully at making my lashes long and thick without all the clumping or spidery-looking lashes. Half the price of the department store brand I used to use. I am knocking off a star because yes, it is nearly impossible to take off, and my makeup remover wipes won't do it. I'll try plain old soap. I think next time the store is out of non-waterproof, I'll just wait and buy elsewhere!

This stuff is darn near impossible to remove from your lashes! Even after multiple makeup removers, I was still left with gunk on my lashes. I had to go a few days without mascara just so the old application would wear off. What hurt the most is that I lost quite a few lashes trying to remove it. I've never had a mascara this bad! This was tossed in the trash.

Ick, made my lashes look horrible!! I bought this because I wanted a waterproof mascara while in labor, and this stuff was a joke, made my lashes look stringy and just horrible!! Wet 'n Wild worked way better for half the price!

It's okay. It doesn't go on that dark....you have to apply like 6 coats to get it thick enough where people will notice it!!