The sponges are too small and they detach from the handle too easily. They fall apart after a few uses.

True this is not the highest quality eye shadow applicator, but it's the perfect disposable version. Soft to use on your eyelids. I use one side a day, and then dispose of it when I use it up days later. This way I keep my eyes healthy and contamination-free. Great to travel with- it comes as a set in a little plastic pouch. I'd definitely buy these again!

Just okay. Tip came off with one use. Inexpensive so not a big deal, but should last longer than one use. Also size would not fit in my eyeshadow case, so would not work for travel.

These applicators are not great - at all. The applicator is flimsy and breaks off after a few uses (The first one I used broke off after the 5th use), so it's a good thing there's an applicator at both ends. It's really cheap, so I guess you get what you pay for; however there are other applicators you can buy elsewhere that are about the same price but are better in quality.

These seem adequate. Only used them once so hopefully with use, they will hold the color a little better. The handles feel nicer than the plastic kind and the tips seem a little better but not spectactular. Well worth the cost.

I like all their other brushes, but these are flimsy and do not hold eye color well.

I just got these yesterday and they are GREAT! Another e.l.f. winner!