Comments about Wet n Wild H2O Proof Liquid Eyeliner, Ultra Black 881, .17 fl oz:

I was hoping a waterproof eyeliner would stay throughout a normal work day, but this came off & stuck to the crease of my eyelids. It smudged when I tried to wipe it. Difficult to remove but won't stay where you want it. This one isn't a winner.

Comments about Wet n Wild H2O Proof Liquid Eyeliner, Ultra Black 881, .17 fl oz:

Has an eye liner
Nothing so far , I don't like it
It doesn't stay

Comments about Wet n Wild H2O Proof Liquid Eyeliner, Ultra Black 881, .17 fl oz:

The eyeliner does not have a good amount of pigment. In an hour the eyeliner starts smearing from my sweat but after I cool down its difficult to fix. Also because of my sweat or natural oils the product seeps down to my eyelashes causing them to clump. You are better off using something else.

Comments about Wet n Wild H2O Proof Liquid Eyeliner, Ultra Black 881, .17 fl oz:

I have tried many more expensive products but none worked as well as this one. Goes on easy and lasts all day even if you get it competely wet. I remove it with mineral oil and always keep cotton swabs handy when applying so mistakes are easiy removed. Highly recommended!

Comments about Wet n Wild H2O Proof Liquid Eyeliner, Ultra Black 881, .17 fl oz:

I've been looking for a true waterproof liner to replace the maybelline one I used for years that was discontinued. This one goes on fairly easy, but flakes after many hours, and is really difficult to completely remove, even with oil. I'll keep looking!

Comments about Wet n Wild H2O Proof Liquid Eyeliner, Ultra Black 881, .17 fl oz:

I have tried ALOT of different eyeliners before and this is truly waterproof. During spring time I get REALLY bad allergies and this I can wear without looking like a raccoon by the end of the day. This even outlasts my Lancôme waterproof mascara. The problem I tend to have is 1) my lashes are long so it sometimes gets on them and then I have a hard time curling them and 2) it is real hard to remove. I find it tends to get stuck in between my eye lashes. Still looking for a good make up remove.r Otherwise I am in love with this product.

Comments about Wet n Wild H2O Proof Liquid Eyeliner, Ultra Black 881, .17 fl oz:

All the bad reviews are not really fair. :(
Cuz,this is really a true waterproof formula.
It stays on my oily lids and made it through a whole day at a waterpark just fine!
Yes, the brush is hard to use without getting some on your lashes.
But,its no different and is the perfect dupe to the famous three letter brand's Li...lasting Waterproof Liner and that one is a lil' under twenty bucks!

All you have to do is just use your own liner brush instead!
Also, since this stuff is literally waterproof, soap and water doesn't work that great.
So you just have to use a dual phase(oil/water combo)makeup remover.
Or you can just use any cleansing oils... such as jojoba oil or olive oil.
The price is killer and the formula rocks!
Imo,this is some awesome waterproof stuff!

Comments about Wet n Wild H2O Proof Liquid Eyeliner, Ultra Black 881, .17 fl oz:

I really love waterproof eyeliners and this is REALLY waterproof. Of course with that being said, it's pretty difficult to removed but I found out that with the help of a creamy-textured facial wash and cotton pads, it makes the process of removing easier. I guess the fact that it's really waterproof is the main reason why this is my go-to liquid liner. It does suck when you mess up because it's such a mess to fix and hard to remove. I don't like how it gets in my lashes because they'd clump together. The liner is long lasting but I notice I would have a very tiny smudges near the corners of my eyes over the cream eye pencil that I apply to brighten my eyes.

Comments about Wet n Wild H2O Proof Liquid Eyeliner, Ultra Black 881, .17 fl oz:

The applicator on this eyeliner is awful and makes it uncomfortable to apply. It smudged all over my upper eye lid through out the day after I had let it thoroughly dry.

Comments about Wet n Wild H2O Proof Liquid Eyeliner, Ultra Black 881, .17 fl oz:

I bought it hoping to be able to use it over the summer (for swimming and such). I WOULD NOT RECOMMEND, unless u like thicker lines and aren't planning on going in the water. It isn't a very good product. The brush is very thick so its hard to get a thin line. Even for the small price I don't think it's a good value. Maybe it's just me but i was not satisfied at all with this product.